External Scrum Master

Last post 10:40 am October 16, 2014
by Anke Maerz
5 replies
Author
Messages
01:33 pm October 8, 2014

Hello,

I recently went for a two day SCRUM training and the trainer told us that the Scrum Master should not be from the same team and should be strictly an outsider (not from the same team) .

Is this correct, is this specified some where in the SCRUM guide line?

Thanks in advance,
Mathew George

03:46 pm October 8, 2014

The Scrum Team is made of one Scrum Master + one Product Owner + one Development Team.
The Scrum Master is clearly a part of the team.

I probably miss something in your question.
What do you mean by "outsider" ?
In wich context did the trainer say that ?

04:15 pm October 8, 2014

He told us that the SCRUM Master should from another SCRUM team, not from the same SCRUM team.

01:13 am October 9, 2014

Please tell me that this is not a Scrum.org training.

08:05 am October 10, 2014

> He told us that the SCRUM Master should
> from another SCRUM team, not from the same SCRUM team.

This is incorrect by definition, since a Scrum Master is a role *on* the Scrum Team.

There can be some benefit in rotating team members, but that's just a general consideration.

10:40 am October 16, 2014

Perhaps he meant "The Scrum Master should not be from the Development Team"? For this would be a reasonable argument, although the Scrum Guide explicitly allows (but not recommends) this constellation, too.